New subscriptions are closed. Thanks for being awesome!

The NotPie Cakery Story

The NotPie Cakery Story

A tale of sending birthday cakes, finding joy, and celebrating people.

In the world of Amanda and Joshua, NotPie means spreading a whole lot of joy while finding ways to celebrate people, no matter your distance.

"When we were kicking around the idea of the bakery, we asked all four kids for their name ideas. The high schooler replied with "Not Pie”, and we just went with it. In the most literal sense, it’s true! We are making amazing cakes without a single pie on the menu. But I love the metaphor of endlessly spreading joy and celebrating people, its not pie — you'll never run out!" ~Amanda

Let's Create a Micro-Cakery

After an unsuccessful attempt to find a birthday cake delivery service for Amanda’s dad, these two long-time entrepreneurs decided to take the plunge into an ecommerce micro-cakery. Collectively, they've spent more than three decades creating and marketing startups for other people. With a desire to get out from behind the desk and use their super powers for the greater good, they set out to start a bakery designed to help people everywhere celebrate!

Through this process, they created an innovative line of cakes featuring unique flavor combinations featuring hand-crafted artisan cakes topped with house-made marshmallow frosting and finished with a chocolate dipped top.

Easy to send, made to order and beautifully packed - a gift from NotPie is sure to delight!

See what we are up to in the bakery

Follow along on Instagram to see what we are baking this week! You can also catch specials, like cake-of-the-month flavors, weekly deals, and new products launches!

Have a question?

Get in touch anytime! Email us at, call us at (669) 232-3402, or message us on social -- find us on twitter and Instagram.