Peanut Butter Cookie Pie

Peanut butter cookie sandwich, filled with a dollop of raspberry jam and vanilla mallow

choose a flavor
  • add Peanut Butter Cookie Pie Six-Pack $29.00
    Oh no! We are all out of Peanut Butter Cookie Pies
  • add Vegan Peanut Butter Cookie Pie Six-Pack $29.00
    Oh no! We are all out of Peanut Butter Cookie Pies
  • add +1 Vegan PB & J Cookie Pie to your box $5.00
    Oh no! We are all out of Peanut Butter Cookie Pies
  • add + 1 PB & J Cookie Pie to your box $5.00
    Oh no! We are all out of Peanut Butter Cookie Pies

+ free shipping!
Peanut Butter Cookie Pie

signature marshmallow top

birthday candle (optional)

a handwritten note

2 day shipping (most places)

These are the cookies you’ve been looking for! Crispy peanut butter cookie pies with raspberry jam, vanilla mallow, and sprinkles.

This isn’t your normal give me all the milk, can’t talk peanut butter cookie. This is her fancy cousin. A crispy rolled peanut butter cookie made with gluten-free flours, brown sugar, and crunchy peanut butter. Then some flaked salt is folded in with few more chopped nuts.

With a generous dollop of bright raspberry jam and a mound of our house vanilla marshmallow fluff sandwiched inside—It’s crispy, gooey, full of jam notes, and conjures up memories of ice cream sandwiches on a hot Summer day.

Weighing in at 4 ounces each, the box of six is definitely big enough to share. Or freeze a few for dessert night in a few weeks.

Available Flavors
$29.00 & free shipping

Peanut butter cookie, raspberry jam, Kosher vanilla mallow, rolled in sprinkles.

$29.00 & free shipping

Vegan peanut butter cookie, raspberry jam, vegan vanilla mallow, rolled in sprinkles

$5.00 & free shipping
$5.00 & free shipping